FINAL SALE: MYSTERY IMPERFECT BASIC TEE

51 reviews
$26
Size Guide
Sizing
SMALL
0-4
MEDIUM
6-10
LARGE
12-16
X-LARGE
18-22
XX-LARGE
22-26

* fits true to size unless otherwise stated

In stock

Description

Our side slit tee is our best seller for a reason. It's relaxed and flattering fit is easy to wear and gives you confidence that your butt is covered while still flaunting your hips. 

  • Tee Will Have Imperfections Including Scuffs, Small holes, Slight Discolorations, Holes, Imperfect or Uneven Side Slits, etc. from manufacturer  (although still able to be rocked with style)
  • Final Sale, No exceptions
  • Tee may or may not be part of our current line
  • Tee may be bleached, cropped, or altered
  • Tee will be a surprise
  • Tee may have slight graphic alterations including but not limited to Different Fonts, Tags, Cuts, Styles, Colors, Designs, Shape
  • Interior Tags may contain colored marks
  • 100% Cotton Tees That Get Softer with Every Wash
  • Base Tees Made from 100% USA-Grown Cotton by Workers Paid a Living Wage
  • Heather Gray Tees are a Tri-Blend of Cotton, Rayon, and Polyester for a Lighter Weight and Softer Touch 


*View our Size Guide to get exact measurements and select your perfect size*

QualityTeeShirtsShirtTeesFitMysteryPebbyShapeSurprise
  • 5 stars: 42 (82%)
  • 4 stars: 7 (14%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 2 (4%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
L
Lindsey K.
Forevee obsessed!

I love all my Pebby Forevee purchases! They're all versatile and unique while making you feel sexy yet comfortable! I even drove 3.5 hours from Pittsburgh to shop at her warehouse sale! It was great!

L
Lacy
ImPERFECT basic tee

I never would order anything this color (burnt orange) but man!!! I love it and I am so glad that my mystery was fulfilled to it's fullest!

K
Kati J.
Perfect t shirts

Great cuts with no noticeable flaws despite being the mystery tees. Thank you! I love them both.

K
KRISTA
Diff color

I love the shirt, but I previously was sent the white shirt, and decided to order more. I put in the special notes that I didn’t want another white one bc I already had one. And I was sent another white one.

M
Molli E.
Love these

I have bought these several times and will buy more, these T shirts fir the best and are the best quality

R
Renbe
Disappointed

Bought 3 mystery tees and got 2 of the same color. So disappointing.

L
Lindsay
Perfectly imperfect

Any of the imperfections work for me. These tees are always great quality. I genuinely enjoy the clothes I get from you guys. I am in a weightloss journey, so the clothing choices I’m making have changed a lot over the last few years.

J
Jennifer T.
Love

I have seriously bought almost 6 or seven mystery packages and I love it because I never know I’m gonna get I’ve loved almost every single item and it’s nice that it’s a surprise when I open it cause it’s like Christmas!

C
Caitlin M.
Comfie & flattering casual

This shirt is perfect for home, running out to the store, sitting in the bleachers at a baseball game, you name it, the perfect go to for my day to day.

K
Kimberly

FINAL SALE: MYSTERY IMPERFECT BASIC TEE

M
Mahinatea C.
Always good quality

Getting so many compliments on this shirt
It feels good, looks good

N
Natalie B.
Basic Tee

This was such a great buy! Material is soft and comfortable. I ordered a medium. The cut of the shirt and size fits in all the right places.

M
Melanie
Perfect fit!!

This is my first time ordering and I absolutely LOVE these shirts!! Great quality and feel!! The cut and style is better than I expected- they really look great on! I have received compliments each time I've worn them out. I'll definitely be ordering again.

T
Tia G.
AMAZING

Everything in my order was fabulous! These t's are now my new obsession. I also purchased the mystery bracelet, in silver. I received theeee coolest cuff ever, and love it. The t's came in a shark skin grey and a heather grey which are perfect for mix and matching with my closet already. Thank you so much for this and I look forward to my next purchase!!

A
Ashley G.
Couldn't find defect

Plain side slits looked great and couldn't find the defect.

L
LBG
Excellent

I loved the shirts!

T
Tabatha B.
MYSTERY IMPERFECT BASIC TEE

I love these tees, so comfy

R
Rosalinda M.
Good

Very nice material very soft. I will be buying more from there.

J
Jessica C.
Love these shirts!

I bought three of these, I got a pretty blue color, and two different grays and they are all in great condition. The lighter gray has a small hole which is a bummer but I knew buying these that they could come with holes.

R
Rae
Mystery sale

Love my Mystery imperfect basic tees!!

L
Latosha
Great quality love the shirts

I love the shirts but you guys sent me 3 of the same exact shirts I thought they were going to be all different because it said mystery

J
Jessica K.

FINAL SALE: MYSTERY IMPERFECT BASIC TEE

N
Nea E.
Imperfect? How?!

The shirt I received was perfect! Didn’t even notice any imperfections at all haha
I’ll definitely grab another one of these in the future 🖤

K
Kelly A.
Soft comfy tee!

This tee is wonderful. It’s so comfy! Only gave 4 stars because mine arrived with a tiny hole in it.

A
Amber C.
Love it

I’ve gotten a medium as well as a small to try out and I LOVE THEM BOTH. Literally on my way to order one more

S
Sarah R.
Not So Basic Tee

This T-shirt may be called a basic tee, but it sure doesn’t make me feel basic!
I love how it accentuates the goods while minimizing the bads.
It washes up great and really does become softer each time!
A huge THANK YOU to Liz for designing a wardrobe staple that every woman can feel proud to wear!

K
Kristen
Customer service is top notch

I ordered 2 and got 2 black ones with 1 being the wrong size. I reached out to customer service with photos of my shirts and they immediately sent out 2 new ones and had me keep the originals. I gave away the really small one. Overall I got black, rust and Heather Grey. The black and rust are a stiff kind of cotton tee, the Heather is soft and drapes better.

Overall I love my pebby shirts! They're customizable as you can notch down at the collar and take the slits higher on the sides like she does in a lot of her ads on this site. Sizing is more of a range- medium on me (size 14ish after baby) is nice across the chest and I did notch the collar and vent the sides extra, large is my goldilocks perfect size, and xl on me is beautifully oversized but still gives me a good shape. I love the shape that's the main thing!!!!! My rectangular mom bod looks great in a tshirt finally! Thanks pebby, you have gained a faithful follower!

S
Sweet C.
Love!

Bought to get out of my all black attire comfort zone! It was a little long in front so I cut the length and cut a little higher side slit! Just added another mystery one to cart!

L
Leticia L.
Mystery Imperfect Basic Tee’s Size L

I love the fit and comfortability of these basic tees for everyday wear or working out. For reference I am 185 and 5’3… the only reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 is because I wish there was a shorter/ petite option… I feel like the tees are a tad too long on me.

×