Buying tops for me is always hit or miss, honestly. With that said, I’m not going to deduct any stars because I ordered the wrong size. That’s “buyer error”. I ordered a large because I saw the oversized cut/fit, and while the sleeves are pretty snug on me, the flowy cropped portion is quite lovely! I’m giving it 4 stars because I expected the fabric to be a bit softer/stretchier, as almost everything I’ve previously ordered from the site has been, but it’s all good! If anything, the sleeves are motivation for me to lose some arm jiggle!